iPhone lovers swear up and down that their cellphone reigns supreme in the case of pictures, but when we had been to blind-test them, would they truly select an iPhone over Android?
Looking for a solution to this query, I blind-tested 20 coworkers who personal iPhones, presenting them with two photos of the identical topic: one taken on a Google Pixel 8 Professional — and the opposite on an iPhone 15 Professional Max.
Let’s examine which pictures, iPhone or Android, gained nearly all of the vote.
Pixel 8 and Pixel 8 Professional evaluation: Take a peek at our digicam samples
The pictures
I went gallivanting via Midtown Manhattan and took some snapshots of standard factors of curiosity, together with the Vessel and the Empire State Constructing.
With out additional ado, let’s get into the outcomes of the blind take a look at.
The Vessel
Pictures of the Vessel, taken with an Android and an iPhone
Credit score: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable
Listed here are two broad photographs of the Vessel, a beehive-like, artsy construction situated in Hudson Yards. The left picture is richer and delivers higher distinction. Nonetheless, the one on the precise seems to make use of software program that enhances the picture’s colours, which makes the golden-brown hues extra placing.
On this picture, the iPhone 15 Professional Max is on the left, and the Google Pixel 8 Professional is on the precise.
The Google Pixel 8 Professional gained the vote right here. I theorize it was victorious as a result of the Pixel 8 Professional seems to be brighter, making the Vessel extra visually interesting. However within the iPhone 15 Professional Max’s protection, it delivered probably the most correct illustration of the scene.
Winner: Google Pixel 8 Professional
Illuminated scorching air balloon
Illuminated scorching air ballon in Hudson Yards, taken with Android and an iPhone
Credit score: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable
Throughout from the Vessel, you will discover a 32-foot, illuminated scorching air ballon inside a sprawling upscale buying heart referred to as “the Retailers.”
Right here, the iPhone 15 Professional Max’s broad shot, situated on the precise, showcases how nicely it recreates coloration precisely. In actual life, the hot-air balloon emanates a surprising, vivid cerulean blue hue. The Google Pixel 8 Professional bought it incorrect right here, reproducing a lilac-esque coloration.
The contributors of the experiments appeared to acknowledge this; most selected the iPhone 15 Professional Max because the winner right here.
Winner: iPhone 15 Professional Max
The Edge
Ultrawide pictures of the Edge, taken with an Android and iPhone.
Credit score: Mashable / Okay
Within the backdrop of this picture, you will discover the Edge, one of the standard commentary decks in Manhattan, overlooking the town.
I switched to ultrawide for these pictures. This one has a transparent winner: Individuals leaned towards the iPhone 15 Professional Max, the picture on the precise. The Apple system completely captured the verdant grass and royal-blue indicators. The Pixel 8 Professional picture, on the left, seems to be a bit washed out.
Winner: iPhone 15 Professional Max
Apple iPhone 15 Professional and Professional Max evaluation: Near perfection
The Empire State Constructing
The Empire State Constructing, taken with an Android and an iPhone.
Credit score: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable
I snapped a 5x zoom picture of the Empire State Constructing after sundown, which kicked in each telephones’ night-mode processes. The precise (Pixel 8 Professional shot) seems to have extra definition and element in comparison with the left, probably on account of Google’s post-processing enhancements. It is a bit too “constrasty” for my tastes.
Curiously, lots of the contributors on this experiment didn’t agree with me; they most well-liked the picture on the precise.
Winner: Google Pixel 8 Professional
Rolex signal
Rolex retailer signal picture, taken with an Android and iPhone.
Credit score: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable
In one other 5x zoom shot, I took photos of a inexperienced LED-lit Rolex signal contained in the Retailers in Hudson Yards.
As soon as once more, it seems to be just like the contributors most well-liked the Google Pixel 8 Professional (proper). The signal seems to be sharper, and there is much less of that “glowy” impact obstructing the letters. The iPhone 15 Professional Max is the primary to characteristic 5x optical zoom; its predecessor maxed out at 3x.
The Pixel sequence, however, delivered 5x optical zoom for the reason that Pixel 7 Professional, so you might argue that Google has had some extra time to good the lens.
Winner: Google Pixel 8 Professional
Last ideas
Do iPhone homeowners truly desire Apple-branded telephones in the case of pictures? Solely in some instances.
In line with this experiment, the iPhone homeowners most well-liked the iDevice for broad and ultrawide photographs. Nonetheless, in the case of zoomed-in pictures, iPhone customers exhibited a desire for the Pixel 8 Professional.
