The Full Transcript
Kristin Hayes: Whats up, and welcome to Assets Radio, a weekly podcast from Assets for the Future. I am your host, Kristin Hayes. At present’s episode is the second in our sequence on electrical automobiles (EVs). As I used to be fascinated by company and matters, I knew early on that I needed to talk to somebody about the way forward for battery know-how. I might argue that how batteries evolve, notably when it comes to vary and price, could make or break the adoption of EVs. So, what would possibly automotive consumers see within the subsequent a long time?
At present, I will be speaking about batteries with Dr. Micah S. Ziegler, an assistant professor at Georgia Tech within the College of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering and the College of Public Coverage. Micah earned his PhD and bachelor’s levels in chemistry, and he now evaluates sustainable vitality and chemical applied sciences, their affect, and their potential. His postdoctoral analysis on the Massachusetts Institute of Know-how (MIT) was notably centered on vitality storage. At present, Micah and I are going to take a deep dive on batteries, and he’ll additionally present some insights from his personal analysis on how greatest to spur innovation on this area transferring ahead.
Two fast notes about our sequence. In case you missed a earlier episode, be happy to click on round within the present notes or the podcast homepage to catch up. In case you determine you needn’t know all the main points about EVs, no worries. Simply tune in once more after a number of weeks once we’ll return to our usually scheduled programming, however after all, I hope you may stick with us.
Hello, Micah. It is a pleasure to speak with you right now, and I am actually glad that you just’re right here on Assets Radio to speak about electrical car battery know-how.
Micah Ziegler: Thanks for having me. I am delighted to be right here.
Kristin Hayes: Nice. Earlier than we get to that subject, I might like to know extra about your background, after all, and specifically, the way you got here to work on clear vitality applied sciences as a chemist.
Micah Ziegler: I have been concerned about addressing environmental points since my childhood. I used to be particularly impressed by visits to nationwide parks. As an undergrad at Yale, I thought-about many various methods I may have an effect. I thought-about working in advocacy or going to regulation faculty, and over time, I discovered that I needed to leverage my curiosity in strengths in science and analysis broadly and apply these to addressing environmental challenges. After a number of years engaged on local weather and vitality coverage on the World Assets Institute in Washington, DC, I made a decision to pursue a PhD in chemistry.
On the time, I already knew that local weather scientists had been doing nice work to explain local weather change and its impacts. I needed to do one thing totally different. I needed to concentrate on learning attainable options to environmental challenges. I selected to check chemistry to raised perceive and contribute to the science that underlies most of the attainable applied sciences we may use to cut back greenhouse gasoline emissions to mitigate local weather change. My first challenge in graduate faculty on the College of California, Berkeley, was truly centered on the way to take carbon dioxide out of the air and switch it into something that was not carbon dioxide.
Towards the ultimate years of my graduate analysis, I discovered myself more and more asking why some applied sciences succeed whereas others don’t. Many issues we will do within the lab by no means make it to broad deployment. For instance, my colleagues may make a man-made leaf that might retailer vitality from daylight by splitting water, however I could not get one for the roof of my condo. I needed to check this hole quantitatively to raised perceive why some applied sciences make it onto the roofs of homes whereas others by no means go away the pages of a lab pocket book; to grasp why some applied sciences enhance quickly whereas others don’t.
I turned to learning vitality techniques and technological change. I studied these topics for a number of years at MIT, as you talked about, and I am persevering with to take action right here at Georgia Tech.
Kristin Hayes: It is nice to have somebody along with your breadth of expertise be part of me to speak about EV batteries, and it’s nice to have a chemist, specifically. Let’s begin with a bit little bit of historic context on the battery facet. My understanding is that within the early days of the automotive business, battery-powered automobiles had been truly developed alongside the standard inside combustion engine car. However basically, inside combustion engine know-how gained out. What did these early EV batteries appear to be, and what’s your sense of why batteries did not keep prevalent early on?
Micah Ziegler: You are totally appropriate. Battery-powered automobiles had been comparatively widespread within the early 1900s. Some estimates recommend that for some time, there have been as many electrical vehicles as there have been gasoline-powered vehicles. These electrical automobiles had been utilized in each private and business contexts. For instance, the US Postal Service in New York Metropolis had a number of electrical vans, which reportedly had the capability to run for 45 miles on a single cost. A lot of these early EV batteries had been lead acid batteries, which had been launched within the late 1850s, a long time earlier.
These batteries contained lead and sulfuric acid. They had been heavy. They required frequent upkeep. Like right now’s EV batteries, many smaller battery cells had been mixed to type the bigger batteries utilized in automobiles. Additionally like right now, there have been competing battery chemistries. Notably, some car producers provided the choice to improve batteries to those who relied on nickel and iron.
In fact, when one know-how outcompetes one other, as gas-powered automobiles outcompeted electrical choices, there are sometimes a number of components that play a job. One main issue right here was that the batteries had been fairly restricted within the quantity of vitality that may very well be saved inside a given weight, what is called the particular vitality. In flip, this actually restricted each the vary and the velocity of those early electrical automobiles.
Furthermore, whereas huge cities had charging infrastructure, past the cities, charging choices had been scarce. As highway infrastructure improved and expanded and gasoline grew to become extra out there, gas-powered cars grew to become extra well-liked. Gasoline-powered vehicles allowed individuals to journey additional and sooner and may very well be refilled past the cities.
One other issue although was the mixing of small batteries into these gasoline-powered automobiles. Beforehand, gas-powered vehicles wanted to be began with a crank. It was exhausting work. Batteries allowed gas-powered automobiles to be began extra simply and in addition powered their lights. In essence, batteries introduced among the comfort related to electrical automobiles on the time to gas-powered choices. Batteries had been nonetheless crucial however as a element within the gas-powered vehicles.
Kristin Hayes: Acquired you. It is attention-grabbing to consider—you talked about charging infrastructure, and it is humorous, I hadn’t even thought of what charging infrastructure in these early days would possibly presumably have appeared like, nevertheless it’s an attention-grabbing psychological picture, and I undoubtedly have a psychological picture of the crank that one would use to start out vehicles.
You additionally referenced totally different battery chemistries. Lead and sulfuric acid do not sound like essentially the most fantastic mixture of chemical compounds, however there definitely are many various combos of supplies. I feel right now, lithium-ion batteries are the commonest battery in use in electrical automobiles and in lots of different purposes however definitely in batteries for EVs. How did that individual mixture of supplies come to dominate?
Micah Ziegler: Researchers have lengthy centered on utilizing lithium in batteries. It’s the third-lightest component, and it helps excessive voltages, which may allow substantial quantities of vitality to be saved in light-weight batteries. For a lot of a long time, individuals have made batteries utilizing lithium metallic, they usually nonetheless do. For instance, among the coin-shaped cells that you just would possibly change each couple of years in small moveable electronics like wi-fi keys typically use lithium metallic. Nonetheless, standard lithium-metal batteries usually are not rechargeable. Makes an attempt to develop batteries that had been rechargeable and relied on metallic lithium have traditionally confronted appreciable challenges. The batteries would typically short-circuit, they usually introduced security issues.
Lithium-ion batteries are totally different. Word the introduction of the phrase “ion” right here. These usually are not the identical as lithium-metal batteries. In lithium-ion batteries, lithium ions intercalate or insert into and out of the anode and the cathode and the supplies on the totally different ends of the battery. This intercalation permits these batteries to keep away from the challenges related to metallic lithium. Notably, the anode of those batteries is often made out of graphite, which consists of flat sheets of carbon atoms. Once you cost a lithium-ion battery, the lithium ions migrate into and sit between these sheets fairly than combining with electrons and changing into lithium metallic. This permits lithium-ion batteries to be recharged far more simply.
When lithium-ion batteries had been launched by Sony within the early Nineteen Nineties, these batteries introduced a serious step up in efficiency in comparison with different rechargeable batteries on the time. They held far more vitality in a given quantity or mass of batteries, which was particularly essential for his or her preliminary purposes in moveable electronics. Moveable electronics like video cameras and laptops and cellphones grew to become more and more well-liked and as you properly know, shoppers desired gadgets that lasted longer on a single cost. Due to this fact, researchers improved battery efficiency considerably, manufacturing elevated considerably, and price dropped dramatically.
A few of my and my colleagues’ current analysis confirmed that over nearly three a long time, the costs of lithium-ion batteries declined by roughly 97 %. In different phrases, batteries right now price lower than 3 % of what they price three a long time in the past. Over the identical time, lithium-ion batteries had been additionally personalized to be used in a spread of purposes, from cellphones to energy instruments, ultimately to automobiles and to stationary storage related to the electrical grid. This enchancment in efficiency and decline in price mixed with that flexibility that allowed lithium-ion batteries to be personalized for various purposes, all of this led to their dominance.
Kristin Hayes: Why are individuals now searching for alternate options then? Possibly I ought to begin that query by saying it definitely does look like individuals at the moment are searching for alternate options to one thing that, as you level out, has been tremendously profitable and widespread and has had a number of worth. Why are we searching for alternate options now?
Micah Ziegler: It is essential to notice that lithium-ion batteries are not composed of only a single mixture of supplies. Relatively, the time period lithium-ion now refers to a constellation of various supplies. Over time, researchers have developed new electron supplies that present quite a lot of enhancements. Some cathode supplies, for instance, change among the cobalt which was used within the authentic lithium-ion batteries with nickel and manganese. This could scale back price and reliance on considerably scarce cobalt whereas additionally growing the quantity of vitality that may be saved. In the meantime, different cathode supplies had been developed that depend on iron and may last more and price even much less.
Nonetheless, you are proper, individuals are nonetheless involved about how and the place these supplies are mined and processed. Some metals for batteries, notably cobalt, are related to human rights abuses. There are issues in regards to the environmental impacts of mining. In the meantime, the processing of those supplies is presently usually restricted to a small handful of nations. There are additionally questions as as to if we will scale the mining and processing of those supplies rapidly sufficient to satisfy demand for our many vitality storage purposes, together with electrifying vehicles and vans, in addition to supporting electrical grids which might be more and more depending on photo voltaic and wind sources. And naturally, researchers and labs around the globe are at all times on the seek for better-performing, lower-cost choices. Mixed, these components have pushed a substantial seek for alternate options.
Kristin Hayes: How does this have an effect on the dialog about vary, too? Actually, you talked about price and the provision of supplies numerous instances. Are we searching for battery chemistries which may truly permit that longer vary that appears to be a giant a part of the dialog round electrical automobiles?
Micah Ziegler: Completely. We’re searching for new battery chemistries, new battery designs—methods to chop down on the burden and quantity related to all of the elements that go into supporting the batteries. Researchers at quite a lot of ranges are attempting to ensure we will basically have electrical automobiles that may journey so far as attainable on a single cost.
Kristin Hayes: A number of the chemistries that I feel are floating on the market as near-term alternate options embody sodium-ion batteries. I might love to speak about that. Then there’s additionally some speak about improvements in so-called “solid-state” batteries. I am questioning, within the context of what we have been speaking about round vary and price, are you able to simply say a bit bit about how these explicit chemistries would possibly present some promise?
Micah Ziegler: Positive. Let’s begin with sodium-ion batteries. Because the title implies, in these batteries, lithium is changed with sodium, and there are different modifications, too; for instance, within the electron supplies. Within the business cells introduced a number of years in the past, the cathode materials depends on iron, and the anode materials makes use of a special type of carbon. Nonetheless, the elemental technique of the ions transferring forwards and backwards between and into and out of the electrodes when charging and discharging stays similar to what we see in lithium-ion batteries. And these sodium-ion batteries are thought-about promising due to their reliance on inexpensive, considerably extra widespread parts. This results in lower-cost batteries which may not face provide limitations.
Nonetheless, the present technology of sodium-ion battery cells can’t retailer as a lot vitality in a given mass or quantity as may be saved by the perfect lithium-ion choices. There are, apparently although, some indications that sodium-ion batteries would possibly carry out higher in decrease temperatures.
Stable-state batteries, which you additionally talked about, differ in one other manner. Notably, lithium-ion battery applied sciences right now depend on a liquid electrolyte. The electrolyte is an answer that helps the lithium ions journey forwards and backwards within the battery. Researchers are attempting exhausting to interchange this liquid with a strong electrolyte. Batteries with strong electrolytes may very well be safer and permit for a better particular vitality, for extra vitality to be held inside a given weight of batteries. Notably, researchers hope that strong electrolytes would possibly permit us to realize the long-standing purpose of safely utilizing lithium metallic in a chargeable battery. Rechargeable lithium-metal batteries with strong electrolytes may permit us to considerably enhance particular vitality past what’s seen in right now’s lithium-ion batteries.
Kristin Hayes: Fascinating. This leads me to one thing I have been very interested in. As this evolution of battery applied sciences is constant, I might love your opinion on whether or not you suppose we’ll find yourself with a mess of battery chemistries throughout the globe, or do you suppose that one will ultimately come to dominate, for example, not less than briefly, as lithium ions have carried out to this point? I take into consideration this not solely within the context of electrical automobiles and the event and deployment of these batteries, however you additionally talked about numerous different purposes. How do you consider that competitors versus consolidation of chemistries over time?
Micah Ziegler: I believe that, going ahead, we’ll see a range of battery chemistries that serve a good wider number of purposes, albeit with lithium nonetheless taking part in a serious position. We have already seen diversification inside the context of lithium-ion batteries and I anticipate that pattern to proceed. Lithium-ion batteries, as I’ve talked about, may be made utilizing totally different combos of electrode supplies to satisfy a spread of efficiency and price targets. Inside this constellation of lithium-ion choices, some battery chemistries retailer a number of vitality in these small, slim cells which we use in our laptops and our cellphones. Different chemistries and designs permit batteries to rapidly launch numerous vitality—for instance, in energy instruments—and nonetheless others stability the necessities for vitality capability and weight and energy to permit electrical automobiles to journey additional and cost quickly.
Because of the light-weight nature of lithium and its electrochemical traits, in addition to the appreciable head begin that lithium-ion applied sciences have, I anticipate they’ll stay a serious participant within the battery area for not less than a number of a long time.
I additionally suspect we are going to see some diversification exterior of the lithium-ion area. As society works to impress our vitality techniques, we’ll want extra choices to retailer electrical vitality for various purposes. These choices may be supplied partly by a spread of various battery chemistries and designs. For instance, there are some battery chemistries being developed particularly for stationary storage to help using photo voltaic and wind energy. In stationary purposes, that light-weight nature of lithium is much less related. There is a distinguished instance: iron-air batteries. However how rapidly these applied sciences will enhance and scale versus lithium ion continues to be an open query.
Kristin Hayes: That is truly an incredible lead right into a little bit of a dialog about your explicit analysis that you just talked about in the beginning. One thing that I feel you are actually concerned about is components that truly affect technological change. How is it that some issues develop extra rapidly and truly get into {the marketplace}, and what holds different issues again? Possibly I can ask you a bit about that and why that is a selected curiosity of yours, and possibly you can say a bit bit, too, about the way you analysis one thing like that?
Micah Ziegler: I actually wish to perceive why some applied sciences succeed and others don’t. What components allow some applied sciences to enhance and are available down in price quickly? As we have seen for photo voltaic panels and batteries, why do different applied sciences keep comparatively the identical over time or typically even enhance in price? I consider that if we higher perceive these components, we can assist extra sustainable applied sciences succeed. Hopefully, we will apply what we be taught to enhance the design of the subsequent technology of applied sciences to allow them to enhance quickly. I additionally intention on this work to tell the design of insurance policies and the course of funding to allow them to allow the success of sustainable choices.
To know these components, I gather a number of empirical real-world information on applied sciences. What goes into these applied sciences? How a lot do these inputs price? How are they manufactured? I attempt to gather information that describe how all of those change over time. Then, utilizing fashions that replicate the underlying physics and chemistry and engineering, I can disentangle how numerous components contributed to technological enchancment. Basically, we’re quantifying the mechanisms of technological change. For instance, utilizing this strategy, my colleagues and I’ve studied how modifications in materials efficiency and costs contributed to the speedy price decline of lithium-ion batteries. We discovered that between the late Nineteen Nineties and the early 2010s, the rise in cell cost density contributed extra to price decline than the lower within the value of cathode supplies. These outcomes can inform the design and engineering of the subsequent technology of batteries.
We additionally, on this work, estimated the contributions from high-level mechanisms of technological change, these typically related to coverage and enterprise decisionmaking, like analysis and growth, studying by doing, and economies of scale. Utilizing this strategy, we discovered that over the identical time interval, the late Nineteen Nineties to the early 2010s, analysis and growth—each private and non-private—contributed extra to the price discount of lithium-ion batteries than did economies of scale. A lot of these outcomes can then inform the design of latest public insurance policies and the way we direct monetary investments.
Kristin Hayes: That’s tremendous attention-grabbing. I might like to ask you to say just a bit bit extra about that when it comes to what we have discovered about batteries. How can policymakers provide you with new insurance policies that may actually intention to speed up a few of this deployment that we actually want both within the battery area or possibly in different sustainable applied sciences, too?
Micah Ziegler: My analysis suggests two main classes for policymakers. The primary emphasizes the significance of continued funding for analysis and growth, and the second highlights sure know-how designs which may allow speedy enchancment.
As I discussed earlier, on this analysis, my colleagues and I discovered that for greater than 20 years after the business introduction of lithium-ion batteries, private and non-private analysis and growth performed a really massive position in price discount, whereas different components like economies of scale contributed much less. Different analysis discovered the same end result for photo voltaic photovoltaic modules—that analysis and growth contributed considerably to price discount properly after photovoltaics had been launched. These outcomes recommend that if policymakers preserve funding for analysis and growth for sustainable applied sciences even properly after these applied sciences are launched to the market, they may speed up the development in deployment of those sustainable choices.
You will need to observe that insurance policies that intention to stimulate demand and develop markets also can encourage personal analysis and growth, so market-expansion insurance policies can complement these insurance policies that extra straight help public analysis and growth efforts. Within the case of lithium-ion batteries, we additionally discovered that entry to a various vary of chemistries may need enabled their speedy enchancment and price decline. As we have mentioned, there are various totally different combos of battery supplies out there that researchers found. Furthermore, when researchers needed to introduce an improved element, they did not must reinvent how these batteries had been designed and manufactured and operated each time an enchancment was made.
This range of chemistries and the power to simply combine these many choices into battery manufacturing may need contributed to the success of lithium-ion batteries. One implication of those findings is that investments, each private and non-private, would possibly allow sooner technological enchancment in the event that they help applied sciences whose designs permit totally different elements to be simply integrated without having to reinvent the entire know-how each time a element is improved. For storage applied sciences particularly, the help may very well be mixed with help for continued exploration of an array of chemistries.
Kristin Hayes: Very attention-grabbing. All proper. I do know we’re virtually on the finish of time. I do wish to ask you another substantive query after which after all, we’ll shut with our common characteristic, however that query is definitely about battery recycling, which is one thing that we have not actually talked about to this point in our dialog right now.
I puzzled in case you may say just a bit bit about that individual subject, whether or not a few of these chemistries in truth lend themselves extra simply to restoration of supplies and reuse of these supplies. How essential would you say innovation in that individual area across the reuse of supplies is compared or alongside the event of those precise new chemistries themselves?
Micah Ziegler: I feel each are essential complementary investments in our future. Creating new chemistries can enhance efficiency, decrease price, and as we have mentioned, possibly scale back our reliance on any given set of supplies. Creating our capability to recycle batteries can be vitally essential. We’re making many billions of lithium-ion battery cells a yr, and constructing the capability to recycle them can assist be sure that the trouble we put into mining and refining the supplies would not go to waste when batteries should be changed. We nonetheless have loads to study the way to recycle batteries effectively and cost-effectively and the way to make sure that the recycled supplies are of the standard essential to make new batteries.
Nonetheless, the contribution of recycling to the provision of supplies for brand new batteries goes to stay restricted for years to return. This outcomes from a lag between when batteries are produced and once they’re recycled. The batteries going into electrical automobiles right now will final for years and thus, the supplies in them will not be out there to be recycled into new batteries for fairly some time. Within the meantime, we’ll nonetheless want supplies to satisfy the rising demand for batteries.
Kristin Hayes: Truthful sufficient. Having simply obtained my electrical car, I can personally say I hope that battery lasts for a few years, and you’ll not be seeing my lithium anytime quickly.
This has been an incredible dialog. I actually recognize this introduction, and I hope of us have loved as a lot as I’ve, studying about each the historical past and the way forward for what’s, once more, I might argue a very crucial a part of the EV revolution, if you’ll. Thanks.
We’ll shut the recording with our common characteristic, Prime of the Stack. I feel all of our listeners know what that’s at this level. Micah, let me simply ask you, what’s on the highest of your stack?
Micah Ziegler: I’ve an eight-month-old daughter, so truthfully, my stack is generally composed of board books. The Very Hungry Caterpillar and All The World are actually huge hits.
In terms of vitality and sustainability, what I am protecting an eye fixed out for are articles and stories that describe community-engagement efforts round vitality initiatives. I am studying about native teams that help and oppose photo voltaic and wind initiatives and researchers’ efforts to interview stakeholders and perceive their issues. Transitioning our vitality system to low-carbon choices requires constructing many new issues. Battery and EV factories, charging stations, mines, recycling services, photo voltaic and wind farms, transmission traces—this stuff is not going to be in-built a vacuum. They’re going to be in-built and close to communities, and the native officers who signify the individuals who will work and stay close to our current and proposed vitality infrastructure ought to be included as decisionmakers alongside challenge builders and regulators. Two-way communication and training between these decisionmakers is essential, and efficient group engagement can foster constructive relationships that stretch past a person challenge or proposal.
That is actually difficult work, and one-size-fits-all approaches appear to be few and much between, nevertheless it’s essential work, in order that’s why I am listening to it.
Kristin Hayes: Nice. All proper. Effectively, hopefully, we’ll have extra alternatives to speak right here on Assets Radio about that subject, as a result of I agree with you, it’s a actually essential and attention-grabbing area to grasp how greatest to maneuver ahead.
Thanks once more, Micah. It has been a pleasure to speak with you.
Micah Ziegler: Thanks a lot. I loved our time.
Kristin Hayes: You have been listening to Assets Radio, a podcast from Assets for the Future, or RFF. When you have a minute, we might actually recognize you leaving us a ranking or a remark in your podcast platform of selection. Additionally, be happy to ship us your ideas for future episodes.
This podcast is made attainable with the beneficiant monetary help of our listeners. You possibly can assist us proceed producing these sorts of discussions on the matters that you just care about by making a donation to Assets for the Future on-line at rff.org/donate.
RFF is an unbiased, nonprofit analysis establishment in Washington, DC. Our mission is to enhance environmental, vitality, and pure useful resource choices via neutral financial analysis and coverage engagement. The views expressed on this podcast are solely these of the podcast company and should differ from these of RFF consultants, its officers, or its administrators. RFF doesn’t take positions on particular legislative proposals.
Assets Radio is produced by Elizabeth Wason, with music by Daniel Raimi. Be a part of us subsequent week for one more episode.